Martin HD-28V Customer Reviews
   

Forum username: WahWah
Date: 01/09/2014
Review: Martin HD-28 V
Rating you give the Martin HD28V: 5 - Best thing I ever played

Likes: everything about this guitar is very fine,no mistakes,really well done work and in my opinion worth any cent you have to pay for it
great unique sound in all the ways you can play it,picking,strumming,rock and blues,very versitale,
never muddy,always each note "sings" along with a unbelievebal sustain

Dislikes: should have bought it 20 years earlier...

Additional Comments: i may be not the best guitarplayer in the world, but i know,now i sound the best :)

Name: Hank
Date: May 30, 2013
Review: HD-28V
Rating you give the Martin HD28V: 1 - Save your money

Likes: Tries to honor the original D-28 and replicate the old bones.

Dislikes: Pretty much a worthless upgrade from a HD-28. If you want to pretend you have a real vintage guitar be my guest.... The bluegrass band boys where I play hate this model thinking it is fake and for posers. I became the ugly ducking in the band with the HD-28V. Personally I think the HD-28V is lacking in cutting power and strength to a good HD-28 as others noted in forums and reviews. Though this guitar has forward shifted bracing it can get really boring to play if you play it for a marathon jam I think rear shifted or standard X bracing sounds better to forward shifted bracing on East Indian as others noticed.

Additional Comments: I bought the guitar from my neighborhood store and they lied to me. The old salesman told me the HD-28V has red spruce on it. But that is a LIE!!! I was not as impressed with the guitar as I thought I would and looked up the specs and it has Sitka Spruce and same wood quality/grade as the standard HD-28. So I tried to return the guitar since the guitar was not what I was told what I was getting. Make sure you know that this guitar is pretty much a Standard HD-28 with the bracing moved only about half an inch! Also a few minor cosmetic changes that the majority of the world does not care about. Okay cool old logo... There are people that freak out if they don't have this logo........ I don't see the big deal and can justify a big price increase for that logo. I personally think the modern Martin logo looks better and it catches the light better and shows everyone you are the king of the stage and you got a Martin! Even the ladies love the new logos better. The HD-28V's logo is not flashy and cannot be read from a distance. Personally i don't care what the logo is. I wouldn't even mind if the new martin logo was of CF Martin IV's moustache. I only bought this guitar thinking I was getting red spruce and was getting a big upgrade from the HD-28 but I am mighty disappointed and I am now plotting a way to get rid of this guitar. Next guitar for me is coming from Maury though.
 

Forum username: Magic Tone
Date: May 26, 2013
Review: HD-28V
Rating you give the Martin HD28V: 2 - Did the job nothing special

Likes: It has a very dark tone that is like dark woody chocolate. It is like splinters of dark magic. Not a bright guitar at all. The highs are turned down for a more bassy dark sound. I say most guitarist would be turned off by the neck or the dark sound, but I sure liked it and bought it I loved the smell of this thing, vintage appointments, and the HERRINGBONE!

Dislikes: I do a lot of alternate tunings. I left the guitar in alternate tuning for a week. When I can back from Dallas and played the guitar. I then heard a crack and now I have a broken HD-28V.(Hopefully warranty covers the repairs) I am the original owner so hopefully everything works out

Additional Comments: It is a good guitar but I don't think it is very versatile now. My friend has the HD-28 and he does fine with alternate tunings and it sounds magical on that model with sparkly highs and dark punchy bass. The HD-28V though not as loud as the HD-28 and probably not as versatile is a great guitar but really nothing special for me now since I feel the guitar limits what I can do musically. When a guitar breaks with alternate tuning its not for me because I like having those options available. Though those few minutes of alternate tuning with my HD-28V were quite enjoyable it did not last long. Maybe the forward shifted bracing had too much pressure with the addition of extra pressure with this alternate tuning. Though I love forward shifted bracing I feel now it is a leash to my creativity. I doubt humidity or temperature caused the damage to the guitar because my house has humidity and temperature in the range recommended by Martin. I am just crossing my fingers my baby gets repaired with the warranty honored, but this time I am staying in standard tuning with it. No fancy tunings for her now.

Name: Gerald
Date: May 15, 2013
Review: Martin HD-28V
Rating you give the Martin HD28V: 1 - Save your money

Likes: Nice way to honor the D-28 series with a vintage look. Case is nice.

Dislikes: Hate the neck on this guitar!  I HATE it with a passion.  It is okay for cowboy chords, but more technically difficult chords are a pain in the... Well you know.  I have had this guitar for a year and play 2 or more hours every day, but that neck is terrible.  My hand begins to cramp playing this. Wish this had the low profile neck.  Sounds good like a Martin should.  Just the playability sucks.  If you just plan on staying below the first five frets for basic playing well this is for you.  If you are a little more sophisticated I recommend a low profile neck.

Additional Comments: Better neck would make this a better guitar.

Name or Forum username: JJ
Date: 5-12-2013
Review: HD-28V
Rating you give the Martin HD-28V: 1 - Save your money

Likes: It's a Martin Dread!

Dislikes: Tone is kind of dull and lacks liveliness. The HD-28V is bland mashed potatoes and a HD-28 is a spicy chicken full with flavor and soul. HD-28V sounds lifeless sadly. I would actually pick a D-28 or a HD-28 over this guitar if I bought again.

Additional Comments: Don't buy into the perception that forward scalloped braces are the ultimate guitar tone. It is not true especially with this design.

Name: Pete
Date: May 11. 2013
Review: HD-28V
Rating you give the Martin HD28V: 1 - Save your money

Likes: Vintage appointments (why I bought it)

Dislikes: Sound is off. Has the pre-war design (kind of), but forward scalloped bracing with only East Indian rosewood does not sound good to my ear now that I have had the guitar for a month I'm sick of this sound. Sounds too dark and muddy and I'm a martin fanboy. Martin advertises this guitar as a replica of a pre-war guitar but it really is not... The bracing is still wrong, wrong herringbone used, wrong backstrip, and the wrong sound. One word summarized the 28V "disappointing", but it has potential if Martin allowed the 28V to get better resonant wood because East Indian and a Sitka top with forward braces lacks excitement especially with a price tag this high.

Additional Comments: I would rather spend my money on a HD-28 since the bracing for that model allows the guitar to be more articulate and focused without over{blocked} muddy sound. Or maybe even a Madagascar guitar would be a more necessary thing to have if seeking a pre-war design since this design was developed originally and still works best with more resonant woods like Brazilian. The East Indian is already a warm wood and paired with this forward bracing sounds too muddy and lacks definition. Gets lost in mixes very easily. Spend your money elsewhere. This guitar is for you if you like strumming a guitar that sounds dirty and really is a guitar you do not plan to record with or if you just like having a guitar that looks old, but still looks new since the details don't add up to a finished product... HD-28V and my producer do not get along with one another. I recommend moving up to the Authentic models made by Martin for a better sound or even moving down to a HD-28 for a closer pre-war sound compared to these mud monster 28v guitars. HD-28V lacks complexity. People just buy these thinking they have a pre-war instrument with this.

Forum username: Old Cowboy
Date: 4/16/2013
Review: HD-28V
Rating you give the Martin HD28V: 1 - Save your money

Likes: That it is a Martin 28 and has herringbone. The case is cool, but not a real Geib case just to make that clear because I have the real ones for my vintage acoustics.

Dislikes: I despise the aged toner on this guitar. Looks FAKE and makes the guitar seem like it is trying to be something that it cannot be. If this is a vintage Martin why does Martin not use the correct binding of the period and trim. The zigzag is totally off after comparing my 44 D-28 to this bugger. This guitar sounds dull and boring it would put me to sleep on the couch since no exciting tones were being created. Neck is not as good as other models. Traded in my HD-28V for the HD-28. Now I am a happy Man. HD-28V sounds too reserved and lifeless. Definitely is just an attempt to just throw vintage appointments onto a guitar and try to sell it for people trying to pose as a long traveled musician. Forward scalloped braces with Indian Rosewood in this configuration is just a NO NO. I would recommend the HD-28 to a real musician that is not self-conscious that there guitar does not have diamonds and old features. This dread would be cool if Martin actually used period correct appointments after charging this much. I guess I was a fool for letting that kid convince me the HD-28V is superior and NO one likes the other "cheaper" models. He probably did all that to get more commission out of me to drop the extra money for the HD-28V......... Yeah that's the reason. OH I almost Forgot the Tuners on this guitar are HORRIBLE!!!! Martins should ship these with good waverly tuners for this price. The D-28 and HD-28 have better reliable tuners than this pitiful butter bean "old jelly bean" tuners.

Additional Comments: Go buy the HD-28 and avoid the V unless you need to play a guitar that has been on the road right away. I just hate the fake look of this HD-28V bought just bought it because the salesman was pushing me to buy this model over the D-28 and HD-28s. Glad I went with my heart and went with the HD-28. I hope the HD-28V finds a nice home, but I have found the perfect dread with the HD-28. Try one you will be hooked on Martins.

Name: Paul
Date: 4/14/2013
Review: HD-28V
Rating you give the Martin HD28V: 2 - Did the job nothing special

Likes: The aged look. Traditional look and original Martin logo. Vintage look

Dislikes: This guitar is modeled after the pre-war Martins that guitar geeks myself hunger for. I have played an original herringbone 28 and that guitar was amazing with a 3D sound that was just amazing with such strong grrrrr and rumble! I made an audio copy of that 28 original herringbone and compared it to my own standard HD-28 and HD-28V. I had my friends try to compare the guitars. 8/10 of my friends that are awesome bluegrass players, Folk, Chet Atkins type guitarist thought the HD-28 standard sounded most closely to the HD-28V. I found that interesting. We also did a test at a bluegrass jam between the 28 series guitars I have. The 28V was not audible at all in the jam. The D-28 standard cut through, but the HD-28 standard was the star of the show. The HD-28 is tone perfection. The 28V is not comparable to a pre-war Martin my friends and I believe the HD-28 probably gets closer to that sound. You have to remember the 28V has East Indian rosewood and the original prewars had the Brazilian. The Brazilian sound is most replicated by the standard HD-28 since the 28V may have forward shifted braces, but the chemistry of that bracing with the East Indian rosewood does not sound right (just sounds different). The 28V also is a guitar that really is not used by professionals. Bluegrass, rock, or folk professional players never reach for the 28V because the standard D-28 and HD-28 are much better suited for creating the music for tomorrow's top charting songs and have a perfect chemistry between wood and bracing which the 28V lacks. I think the HD-28 Standard is the dread all others should be measured by now because it creates sonic perfection if you find the right one. Also the HD-28 was designed specifically for creating the best sound possible using East Indian rosewood. The standard D-28's design was leftovers from the transition in the late 60's from Brazilian. The HD-28V is just created to fill an urge that we can own a pre-war D-28. People were just budging martin to reintroduce the forward shifted bracing even though the current wood type does not create the best sound with that variety of rosewood. Also, no major recording have been made with a 28V yet. I know the HD-28 and D-28 are in the studios where I am in Nashville all the time. I strongly recommend if you want to be a great player and not just try to pretend to have a pre-war then avoid this model. The D-28 and HD-28 are guitars for changing music. The 28V kind of sounds like the guitar I would use if I was performing at a funeral it just has a depressing vibe that it fails to be what it set out to be.

Additional Comments: 45 years of playing guitar and 27 years as a studio guitarist in Nashville.

Maury has better prices than other stores (just email him) you will be glad you did :)

Current gear I use:
HD-28 2011 * highly recommend this model best East Indian Martin in production
HD-28V 2009
D-28 1966
000-18GE 2010
000-28EC 2007

Name: Orison Rollins
Date: 2/5/2011
Review: Martin HD-28V
Rating you give the HD28V: 5 - Best thing I ever played

Likes: Powerful, bassy tone, mingled with solid highs. An HD-28 on steroids! It is just as much a cannon as an HD-28, but has a certain smoothness in tone. A fine looking classic Martin!

Dislikes: "Nadda"

Forum username: Terry GTRPLR
Date: 2-25-09
Review: Martin HD-28 V
Rating you give the Martin HD28V: 5 - Best thing I ever played

Likes: The Best volume, tone,and voice of ANY new guitar I've ever played. period

Dislikes: Factory tuning machines.

Additional Comments: Having a bluegrass band, I would NOT use anything else,other than my D-18v.  I use them both on stage, and in the studio.